Starting school at seven boosts reading and other skills.
According to a report in today’s Daily Telegraph researchers in New Zealand have confirmed what some parents have suspected all along. Starting school at a later age can actually boost reading and other skills.
Whilst the UK government is pushing ahead with plans to introduce a new Early Years Foundation Stage curriculum this September placing greater emphasis on the three-Rs with compulsory progress checks and testing from age two, leading academics from Regensburg University in Germany and Otago University in New Zealand have discovered that pupils kept out of formal schooling until the age of seven perform just as well those subjected to normal lessons at five. In fact in some assessments of reading skills, those with a later start often overtook their peers by the time they were ready to leave primary education.
The academics tracked hundreds of children finding that infants given more time to naturally develop their language skills in the early years had a better foundation when they started conventional education at seven than those who started earlier.
Children being pushed too hard
The results come amid claims that children in the United Kingdom are being pushed too hard too early. At present, nurseries and childminders are expected to follow a compulsory pre-school curriculum based largely on academic achievement with targeted expectation of outcomes.
In the United Kingdom children start school by age five with most actually attending reception classes from just four years old. Elsewhere in Europe children start school aged six and in Scandinavia, Bulgaria and Poland, children don’t commence formal education until after their seventh birthday.
The UK compulsory school starting age actually dates back to the 1870 Education Act when the reasons put forward in support of setting the school starting age at five were related to child protection from exploitation and a political wish to appease future employers rather than on the basis of any developmental or educational criteria.
So who’s right?
Despite growing evidence to the contrary the UK Department for Education still believe that the three-Rs should form the bedrock of education and suggests that there is a wealth of international evidence which shows how much each additional month of education benefits a child’s development and achievement by age 11.
But almost everywhere else in the world the school starting age is higher and this latest study, published in the journal Early Childhood Research Quarterly, suggests that success at reading, for example, is not assured by an earlier beginning. Even in the USA, traditionally viewed as a pushy society, over 80% of children don’t start school until six or seven and research there shows that bright children actually benefit from being slowed down in the early years to avoid the risk of growing up “intellectually unbalanced” as a result of being pushed too far too soon.
Children need time to learn through play.
Steiner schools have always maintained that children need more time to develop at their own pace and indeed ban the use of written language up to seven years in order to encourage the development of oral communication and other forms of expression. Children subsequently spend more time on play-based activities, such as painting, drawing, cooking, singing or oral storytelling.
Putting on my “Music Bus” hat for a minute I find myself welcoming Dr Sebastian Suggate’s research. I have always maintained the importance of play and music in particular in a child’s development and education. Learning through song and movement and the playing of simple percussion instruments has an enormously positive effect on children and reaches far beyond the immediately obvious benefits of having a fun and stimulating time with their peers.
Music makes learning fun!
Simple counting songs, story songs and learning how to cope with the subtle nuances of pitch and rhythm have a positive effect on everything from speech development, language skills, numeracy, hand eye coordination and memory. It’s not for nothing that music is known as the universal language and I believe we should be encouraging greater use of music and expression during nursery years and beyond into the primary classroom.
As to school starting age, there’s a huge debate to be had, but I wonder, in a society which seems to pile on the pressure to achieve and leaves many kids burned out by their teens is it right to force them through an educational system that forces them through so many academic hoops at such an early age?
At Music Bus we’ve always believed in “Making Music Fun” maybe it’s time to change our slogan to “Making Learning Fun”?
What do you think?







